Page 1 of 2

Male or Female? - Help identifying this bird

Posted: 23 Jun 2021, 08:27
by gschneiders
I got this bird today thinking it's a single factor yellow male, black face, purple breast, but now I am wondering if it can be a female. I have a yellow female and this bird is a bit darker than she is, however, the purple breast is not as bright as the other male I have. It's a juvenile bird going through its first molt and it has not sang yet.

Please let me know what you think.

Thank you!

Image
[Image
Image

Re: Male or Female? - Help identifying this bird

Posted: 23 Jun 2021, 11:27
by elferoz777
looks male to me

Re: Male or Female? - Help identifying this bird

Posted: 23 Jun 2021, 12:15
by finchbreeder
I would think a male, however the brightest female and the dullest male = the same colour. So treat it as male, but be willing to be pleasantly surprised.

Re: Male or Female? - Help identifying this bird

Posted: 23 Jun 2021, 17:06
by garyh
i would think hen,head colour on cocks is darker,breast colour is light ,no extended tail feathers,overal colour light,glad to be wrong cheers garyh

Re: Male or Female? - Help identifying this bird

Posted: 23 Jun 2021, 21:57
by gschneiders
Thank you all that replied. my initial thought is that this is a SF yellow, as there is some green developing on it's neck and back, hence I thought it was a male.

Thank you for your comments.

Re: Male or Female? - Help identifying this bird

Posted: 30 Jun 2021, 17:20
by Gympie birds
Hen

Re: Male or Female? - Help identifying this bird

Posted: 30 Jun 2021, 17:22
by Gympie birds
Hen as hens in the yellow colour tend to have a dark pink beek during breeding season. I based this on past observations could be wrong though.

Re: Male or Female? - Help identifying this bird

Posted: 01 Jul 2021, 14:27
by Shane Gowland
I'm thinking hen because you would expect a male to have longer tail feathers in early summer.

Re: Male or Female? - Help identifying this bird

Posted: 01 Jul 2021, 20:10
by finchbreeder
Gary and Shane make a good point - that I had missed - re the tail feathers.

Re: Male or Female? - Help identifying this bird

Posted: 07 Jul 2021, 09:05
by gschneiders
Shane Gowland wrote: 01 Jul 2021, 14:27 I'm thinking hen because you would expect a male to have longer tail feathers in early summer.
I agree with you all about the tail feathers, but this bird probably just completed it's first molt from its juvenile color. it was in a store with very poor food (millet only), and it is about 2/3 of the size of the other birds, hence the tail feathers are just starting to form. It is very possible it is a female though. I will let you know once I have the final answer. Just wanted to get the input of more experienced people as I haven't had any dilute nor SF yellow yet. I do have a yellow female (white breast, red head), and her yellow is much brighter than the one on this bird too.

The picture below is the bird now, besides a yellow female, green female and blue male.

Image