Page 3 of 4

Re: needling believe it or not

Posted: 19 Nov 2010, 10:51
by gomer
Its supposed to be like water devining.I think some people believe everything has a inner or magnetic force.So I suppose the metal would react to a magnetic force,If that was so maybe males and females would have a diferent magnetic field,or what ever is causing the change in swing.I personally dont believe in non ferous metals working or checking human unborn babies.All I know is I have a very good hit rate with it, that I cant explain on birds.But as said before on monomorphic birds I still get some DNA.

Re: needling believe it or not

Posted: 19 Nov 2010, 16:46
by VR1Ton
My Grandfather used to do it for canaries, & would get near on 100%. No good if you get DT's though

Re: needling believe it or not

Posted: 19 Nov 2010, 16:58
by avishoot
needling can be 99.999% accurate !! take a blood sample with it and send for DNA testing.posting.php?mode=reply&f=39&t=4955#

Re: needling believe it or not

Posted: 20 Nov 2010, 18:51
by BENSONSAN
Gomer i just got on here finally been on holidays and havent checked the forum im gonna do it and will let you all know what results i get on this darn black headed yellow gould.

Ben

Re: needling believe it or not

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 08:47
by COUNTRY CAPITAL
Hey Dano-68....caught your story in the QFS about diamond sexing,good on u,i need all the help sexing them i can get.
85% success rate is pretty good
99.9% with immatures blows me away......by the way how many did you try to miss 0.1% !!!!

Not sure if i agree 100% as some show opposite traits but if we can be correct 85% of the time thats pretty good.

Maybe we need a boffin who could experiment with ultra violet lights or such because the birds have no trouble telling each other apart, so they see something that we dont.

Magnetic fields/needling etc not so sure...... no bridges/towers needed up this way.

cc :thumbup:

Re: needling believe it or not

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 13:04
by MadHatter
COUNTRY CAPITAL wrote: Maybe we need a boffin who could experiment with ultra violet lights or such because the birds have no trouble telling each other apart, so they see something that we dont.
I've often wondered if putting them under a blacklight might pick up some visual cues that might not be visible otherwise, but have never had the opportunity to test it out...

Re: needling believe it or not

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 13:27
by Jayburd
having seen budgies and starlings under a black light WOW they are cool... I'm gonna try some RFPF's under one of those some day

Re: needling believe it or not

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 13:46
by Diane
I mentioned this before with reference to Gouldians and the head colours and Im getting more convinced about it now, they have to be seeing different colour spectrum in cocks and hens.

Re: needling believe it or not

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 14:46
by MadHatter
Jayburd wrote:having seen budgies and starlings under a black light WOW they are cool... I'm gonna try some RFPF's under one of those some day
You're not referring to the footage on The Life of Birds by any chance are you?

Re: needling believe it or not

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 16:17
by Jayburd
Yep :D love david attenborough, missed meeting him when he was in Oz by 1 HOUR!!! frustrating. anyone else ever heard of Gerald Durrell? My Idol :soppy: wish I could have met him... might visit his zoo one day :)