E Orix wrote:I thought to get a good quality Finch for the show bench you had type as the bench mark.
Breeding longer or shorter beaks dismisses the type.
I know Bengales are a fertile hybrid but a line has to be drawn some where.
Today Budgies being benched are nothing like the original(type),ugly boof headed individuals.
Zebras are so big they are nearly Diamond Firetail size, why.
Imagine benching a Longtail(Back Heart),big body, big head, good feather but a smaller tail
without the curls, does it beat a smaller bird but with a proper tail ??? it's called a Longtail for a reason.
How often do we see a Gouldian with that proper tail configuration, two long thin tail feathers.
I can remember judges including I just turning boxes around because of lack of type and ignoring
feather condition and size.
This is one reason why showing is far less popular than years ago.
I agree with most of your comments.
I'm not sure of the line you're referring to here. There is a great deal of variation in Bengalese (and all finches) type as well as things like beak size to a degree. My point really is to agree with Craig that the beak on this one is fairly long compared to most Bengos, so if I had to choose between two of these to keep in my stock, one with a more normal
in proportion beak and one that is more elongated like this I would cull the latter. I dont see whats wrong in selecting for an ideal bird. However, as I did mention, details like this are secondary to good type, feather and markings.
I think that the lack of ideal features these days on Finches like Longtails are Gouldians (e.g. Tails and orange breast bar etc.) is mainly due to the lack of Exhibition breeders (or breeders in general) who would normally take the time to select birds that were strong in these traits as the Exhibition Standard will call for such things. These days the general decline in good colour, type, markings and features of Finches is primarily because there are fewer breeders who intentionally pair up ideal birds (like the exhibitors did) rather than have random colonies or whatever comes to hand. I wish there was a larger following of Finch exhibiting than there is, it would be a shame to loose this aspect of our hobby.
Just for my own two cents and "opinion", I don't believe that the Bengalese is a hybrid any more than a Ruddie is (possibly a mixture of subspecies if at all).
Thanks for the feedback.